Skip to main content

Click "Archive" or "Labels" in the sidebar to browse reviews, or use the search bar to look for a specific title.


Review: Brain Camp

Brain Camp Brain Camp by Susan Kim
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

3.45 stars.

It took me a long time to finally pick this up because I don’t have a very great track-record with its publisher, First Second. I’ve read three other books published by them, Anya’s Ghost, and Boxers and Saints. All of these books were good but… unsettling or unsatisfactory in some way, and that’s the impression I’m left with whenever I think of them.

I think Brain Camp may be my favorite First Second book I’ve read… either this or Saints. The story was interesting but jarring at the same time, because I didn’t really expect it to be as creepy as it was. There’s blood and a gross act of plunging a hand into someone’s throat. When things like that happened it was like I said: Jarring. And I'm someone who likes me some weird shit, okay? But whenever it happened here it always seemed like it came out of left field and didn't match the tone of the rest of the book.

I enjoyed this book overall, however I would have enjoyed it a lot more if the storytelling was smoother. It moved way too fast. One frame they’re here, the next frame they’re there, and it was really… Just, bad and not well done, and I would have liked Brain Camp a lot more if the pacing was better. I mean, there were THREE people working on this book (plus editors and such), and no one caught on to how bad that was? Ever heard of first making a storyboard and mapping out your panels and then revising them before going ahead and inking/colouring something that's way too rushed? No? I can tell. This overarching issue with pacing was the main thing that gave the whole book an unsettling feeling overall.

The art has the same thick cartoony style like most other First Second books, but I liked it.

View all my reviews
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

Review: The Art of the Adventures of Tintin

The Art of the Adventures of Tintin by Chris Guise My rating: 5 of 5 stars The Art of The Adventures of Tintin was even better than I could have ever dreamed. This is my first "Art of" book, and I kind of knew what I was getting into but I was still surprised. I didn't even mean to start reading this when I started reading this. We were given an assignment in art class to design a poster for the school play and I really had no ideas. I remembered that these "Art of" books are full of concept art so I decided to flip through this one. Well, next thing I knew I wasn't just flipping through it, I was completely engrossed in it. I flipped to the first page and started properly reading it. This book was a good reading experience. Right off the bat Chris Guise lets the reader know that he's not going to bombard you with text, that he's gonna let the art do most of the talking and he's going to make the best "Ar...
Post a Comment
Read more

Review: Bitter Witness: Otto Dix and the Great War

Bitter Witness: Otto Dix and the Great War by Linda F. McGreevy My rating: 0 of 5 stars This is a very unique and interesting academic text. There are no other examinations of the German artist Otto Dix, his war experience, and his war-related art that are quite as in-depth as this one, while also covering a wide range of different aspects and angles of not only the artist's story, but also the Great War's. I used this as a source for a University research essay I wrote on the effects of Dix's war experience on the creation and effects of his painting Skat Players (1920). I was very late in starting my research so I unfortunately had to stick to only reading the information I could use for my own examination, rather than being able to devour this book in its entirety. However, the library requires this book be returned at the end of January of next year, so I have some time now to actually finish this book since the semester has finished...
Post a Comment
Read more

Review: Miki Falls, Volume 1: Spring

Miki Falls, Volume 1: Spring by Mark Crilley My rating: 4 of 5 stars I can’t lie, I did not have very high expectations going into this book. That’s probably because I always can’t help but fear the worst whenever I read something written by someone I’m familiar with, whether it be a friend, an author whose book(s) I’ve read before, or in this case, someone whose YouTube videos I had begun watching in grade 5. Those videos are the reason I bought this series, but I’ve been apprehensive to read them for a while now for the aforementioned reason, and also because this is Crilley’s first manga venture and I knew that the art was going to be a bit… Off. I can’t say that I was wrong about the art, but as for the rest of the book I was happily surprised. The concept of this book is along the lines of things I’ve read millions of times before, however it has been twisted on its head and I found myself liking it a lot. In the past, I've complained about ...
Post a Comment
Read more